Founder intent and beneficiary interests in the Polish family foundation: Lessons from the matter of Dumont
PDF (Polish)

Keywords

fundacja rodzinna
wola fundatora
interesy beneficjentów
wytyczne inwestycyjne
odpowiedzialność zarządu
prawo trustów
prawo prywatne porównawcze

Abstract

The issue addressed by this article concerns how the management board of a Polish family foundation should respond when continued compliance with a founder-imposed investment direction becomes economically harmful. The Family Foundation Act allows the founder to shape the foundation’s detailed purposes and investment policy, but it does not expressly determine how the board should reconcile those directions with the foundation’s statutory purpose, the interests of beneficiaries and its duties concerning liquidity, solvency and due care. The article examines Matter of Dumont and the American rules governing trust investment as comparative material rather than as rules directly applicable in Poland. It distinguishes non-binding investment guidelines from binding provisions of the foundation’s charter. A non-binding direction should not replace the board's own informed assessment and may be departed from where continued adherence would materially endanger the foundation. A binding charter provision must first be interpreted in light of Article 2 of the Family Foundation Act and any available escape clause; if necessary, the amendment procedure should be pursued, while dissolution should remain a last resort. The article concludes that liability under Article 75 depends both on the legal basis of the board's decision and on the quality of the decision-making process, including the reliability and contemporaneous character of the analyses obtained.

PDF (Polish)

References

Bańczyk W.: spadkobierca nieruchomości położonej w Polsce powołany na podstawie testamentu z wykorzystaniem konstrukcji trustu oraz personal representative (uwagi na tle postanowienia sn z 17.12.2020 r., III CsK 141/18), Państwo i Prawo 2023, no. 11.

Bańczyk W. (in:) Ustawa o fundacji rodzinnej. Komentarz, ed. K. Osajda, Warszawa 2025.

Bender P., Miłaszewski J. (in:) Ustawa o fundacji rodzinnej. Komentarz, ed. K. Osajda, Warszawa 2025.

Bishwas P.C., Hossain M.S.: Does ownership concentration have an impact on financial performance of firms?, 11 Future Business Journal, article 86 (2025).

Cooper J.A.: empty Promises: settlor’s Intent, the Uniform Trust Code, and the Future of Trust Investment Law, 88 Boston University Law Review 1165-1216 (2008).

Górniak K. (in:) Ustawa o fundacji rodzinnej. Komentarz, ed. K. Osajda, Warszawa 2025.

Grzegorczyk K. (in:) Ustawa o fundacji rodzinnej. Komentarz, ed. K. Osajda, Warszawa 2025.

Hansmann H., Mattei U.: The Functions of Trust Law: A Comparative Legal and economic Analysis, 73 New York University Law Review 434-479 (1998).

Herbet A.: new Prospects for wealth management in Poland? General Characteristics of the Family Foundation under the Act of 26 January 2023, Forum Prawnicze 2024, no. 4.

Hess A.M., Bogert G.G., Bogert G.T.: The Law of Trusts and Trustees, Westlaw (database updated May 2025).

Jones G.H.: The Dead Hand and the Law of Trusts (in:) Death, Taxes and Family Property, ed. E.C. Halbach Jr., St. Paul 1977.

Kidyba A.: Klęska tzw. fundacji rodzinnej, Monitor Prawniczy 2025, no. 9.

Kiziah T.S., Campbell L.J.: Drafting to effectuate grantor’s retention desires with respect to publicly held securities, 46(2) Real Property, Trust and Estate Law Journal 199-254 (2011).

Konarski M.: Fundator - prawa i obowiązki (in:) Fundacje rodzinne. Aspekty prawne i podatkowe, ed. A. Mariański, Warszawa 2023.

Kozioł N.: Fundacja rodzinna - nowa instytucja w polskim prawie, Przegląd Prawa Handlowego 2024, no. 10.

Langbein J.H.: mandatory Rules in the Law of Trusts, 98 Northwestern University Law Review 1105–1128 (2004).

Leslie M.B.: Trusting Trustees: Fiduciary Duties and the Limits of Default Rules, 94 Georgetown Law Journal 67-120 (2005).

Nadler J. (in:) Kodeks cywilny. Komentarz, eds. E. Gniewek, P. Machnikowski, Warszawa 2025.

Shaping the status of Heirs by Contractual Components under the Polish and German Inheritance Law: Comparative Challenges and Perspective of Approximation of Legal systems, eds. B. Kucia, E. Macierzyńska-Franaszczyk, E. Rott-Pietrzyk, F. Zoll, Göttingen 2023.

Słup P. (in:) Ustawa o fundacji rodzinnej. Komentarz, ed. K. Osajda, Warszawa 2025.

Sterk S.E.: Trust Protectors, Agency Costs, and Fiduciary Duty, 27 Cardozo Law Review 2761-2806 (2006).

Stępień P. (in:) Fundacja rodzinna. Aspekty prawne i podatkowe. Komentarz, ed. P. Tomczykowski, Warszawa 2023.

Zachariasiewicz M.: Trust i inne stosunki powiernicze w prawie porównawczym i prawie prywatnym międzynarodowym, Katowice 2016.